Identity and Work
I was going to title this Identity, Work, Motherhood and Death, but that seemed a touch too ambitious. Nonetheless, all apply.
On August 31, at the turn from midnight to midnight-01, and for the first time since I was 15 years old, I became unemployed. Sheesh.
Actually, I’m self-employed now and giving a good go at establishing this new career. Still, there’s the tenacious pull of my 30-year academic career. And it’s being impressive – even a little surprising to me how that particular turn of the clock registered as such a huge slam to my identity – to the story I tell myself of who I am.
Admitting this is weirdly embarrassing. After all, I’ve understood for a long time that true identity is way more enduring than any role. The problem, however, seems to be in the word “understood.” Turns out enduring identity can’t ever be fully defined.
Believe me, I’ve tried to wrestle all this identity stuff to the ground with my thinking – heck, I’ve spent 30 years as an academic – but thinking identity into submission, well, it’s never worked. And so, being inescapably human, I’ve caught myself in a near-death grip with one identity after another.
Before the other night, I got to know the transition into empty nestdom. The enormity of its impact on my sense of who I am was similarly surprising – albeit a bit more gradual. I remember the cross-country road-trip with my college-bound daughter. I also remember putting her on a plane after her visit back home over winter holiday break. How cold and empty the house felt. How it felt that way pretty much without exception until, ten years later and a few months ago, when I finally sold it.
All those years, and I’d never consciously experienced how essential the role mother was – and is – to knowing who I know myself to be.
Somewhere mid-Sara’s-childhood I had first heard an age-old Hindu question. 4000 years, plus.
Who are you?
Often repeated this way.
Who are you, really?
I know of few other things as old as these words. Off that short list, Sandhill Cranes may be the coolest – weighing in at 2.5 million years. Among birds, they’re the ones ornithologists recognize as going back the farthest. Or, said another way, the Sandhill Cranes in our skies today have a string of ancestors that have survived extinction the very longest.
Sandhill Cranes mate for life. They do remarkable dances to get themselves to that status. And over the time human beings have been around, they’ve inspired great art. Without knowing and without caring.
Who are Sandhill Cranes, really?
In the agonizing run-up to this moment of formal disengagement from the academy – for now – I’ve come to take stock of one of my unconscious answer to the ancient Hindu question. I’m seeing this, because it’s no longer the easy response it once was. “What do you do?” “Oh, I’m a professor.” “What do you teach?” “Well, I help prepare people to be educators, therapists and public leaders.”
It was good work and it’s ended too early. But it has ended. And here I am with the limits of identifying hanging out everywhere. The embarrassment I mentioned already is, of course, the petty egoic kind. The depth of my socialization into equating personal value with profession has been revealed as bone deep to my everyday sense of what this body, its thoughts and actions, its breath are for.
All these year of thinking. To the limits of my rigor, I’ve taken the question to mind and to heart. Who are you really? It hasn’t been for nothing.
There’s another old saying – from the Sufi tradition – as old as those Hindu words, if not old as the birds.
You are lucky if you die before you die.
Cranes, of course, don’t know much about dying. Their bodies are born, they fly on long and achingly precise curves of wing, and one day their bodies drop. But who they are is who they are. Relevant and irrelevant at the same time in the way of any identity.
My active identity as a mother has died. Yet, still and always, until my body drops, I’ll be a mother. Now, active identity as an employed academic is done. Dead. It remains to be seen if that will revive as an anchor to the roles I play. Who knows.
Seems to me the pain I’m feeling now is likely liberation in disguise. Dying before death seems a mighty liberated state. Like a crane on the wing. A way of being – without any identity at all.
Hi Mary,
I know about these big shifts in work identity and I’m frankly dreading the letting-go-of-my-daughters-shift. But what I can say is that after the dust settles, I find so much of my “old” identity continuing and informing my “new” work identity……I bring so much of my artist past–and present –to my school psych work. So, I’m reminded that identity is as continuous–and as changing–as the body itself: we shed individual cells all the time but the underlying structure and genetics endure until that last day. I have every faith in your changes. Onward!
I hear you so well. I think you are emerging from a cocoon, soon to fly on a different path – a better one. Thanks to Wendy Willis, I saw this. With love and great hope for the next stage.
Years ago I saw a tv show I’ve never forgotten. Can you believe it? Loretta Young did these 30 minute dramas on early tv. In the one I remember she went door to door asking people “who are you?” The replies were always roles until she came to someone who said,”I am ‘their name.'” That was the right answer – at least within this story. And I have always thought it is right. Karen is who I will always be no matter what I do. Thanks for bringing this memory back.